Best Toaster for Even Browning – Top 7 Options

Disclosure: As Amazon Associates we earn from qualifying purchases. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no additional cost to you.

Are you trying to find the best toaster for even browning? You’ve come to the right place. We’ve compiled the top options along with everything you should know before buying…

Best Toaster for Even Browning

Toast is not just for breakfast anymore. With the new popularity of avocado toast, people use their toasters to get creative in the kitchen with all kinds of toppings. You want your meal to start with an even foundation. 

Let’s get to the toasters…

Quick Summary

Product Name Grade
2 Slice Toaster by Oster A
2 Slice Toaster by Opinio A
Extra Wide 4 Slice Slot Toaster by Hamilton Beach A
4 Slice Toaster by Cusibox A+
2 Slice Bagel Toaster by Nostalgia A+
Savoy Toaster by Krups A
CPT-340 Toaster by Cuisinart A+

Best Toasters for Even Browning

2 Slice Toaster by Oster

Oster 2 Slice Toaster, Brushed Stainless Steel (TSSTJC5BBK)

Check Price on Amazon >>

This simple Oster two-slice model will give you all the basics that you need. Each slot is extra-wide, which will fit a variety of bread, bagels, and English muffins. With this toaster, you know you will get even browning every time with Oster’s advanced toasting technology.

There are convenient one-touch preset buttons set for bagel, toast, warm, frozen, and cancel for quick use. This way, you will not have to guess at turning the dial to find the correct toasting time to get your perfect brown.

This toaster does include seven toast settings, from light to dark, marked by numbers on the dial. Use the easy dial number system to choose your perfect shade of brown. With this method, your avocado toast will come out perfectly every time.

What’s better is the crumb tray is removable and dishwasher-safe for perfect clean. And the toaster is encased in cool-touch housing, ensuring no one gets burnt.

This model also boasts anti-jam technology. This will automatically shut the toaster off if a piece of bread gets stuck. This is a crucial fire safety feature.

Pros

  • Wide two-slice capacity gives you the freedom to toast any bread, bagel, or English muffin.
  • Preset one-touch button setting for bagel, toast, warm, and frozen to a no-guess toasting experience.
  • A cancel button allows you to stop the toaster at any time.
  • Seven toast settings are clearly marked on the dial.
  • The use of Oster’s Advanced Toasting Technology ensures even browning every time.
  • Removal and dishwasher-safe crumb trays help to keep your counters clean.
  • Anti-jam technology automatically shuts off the toaster in the event of a jam, keeping this model safe for any time use.

Cons

  • A few users reported that this toaster only lasted about a year before it broke.

Related Article: Best Bread Machine for Beginners (Top 7 Options)

2 Slice Toaster by Opinio

Check Price on Amazon >>

Ready to up your gourmet toast game? This Opinio model will help you do just that.

Featuring six adjustable browning settings, you can easily choose how you want your bread without guessing. There are also settings for defrosting and reheating should you need to perform one of those functions.

With this toaster’s extra-wide two-slice capacity, you can easily toast any bread, bagel, or frozen waffle. You’ll never have to worry if your bread is too thick or too thin as the automatic adjusting toasting cage will close around anything you desire to toast.

A great extra feature you will notice is the extra baking rack. This is what makes this toaster really unique. Simply pop on the baking rack, and you can heat a croissant, sandwich, or anything else while the toaster is in use. The baking rack is easily removable when you are done with it.

This toaster also comes with a convenient dust cap. This will keep your toaster clean and dust-free when not in use. A messy countertop will not be an issue with this toaster. The crumb tray is removable for easy cleaning. And the addition of a cord wrap ensures a tidy look when not in use.

Pros

  • An additional baking rack gives you the ability to make more than just toast.
  • Use the provided dust cap to keep your toaster free of everyday debris.
  • This model comes with six browning selections.
  • The reheat and defrost function helps you do both without guessing.
  • The cancel button allows you to stop toasting at any time.
  • The extra-wide toasting slots allow you to brown any bread without the worry of a jam.
  • A removal, easy to clean, crumb tray keeps mess away.
  • The convenient cord wrap keeps your counter space tidy.

Cons

  • Some users report that this toaster does not pop the bread back up high enough for easy retrieval after toasting.
  • Other users noted that the toasting slots get very hot, creating a challenge to remove bread after cooking.

You Might Also Like: Best Oven Thermometer For Baking (Top 5 Choices)

Extra Wide 4 Slice Slot Toaster by Hamilton Beach

Hamilton Beach Extra Wide Slot Toaster with Defrost and Bagel Functions Shade Selector, Toast Boost, Auto-Shutoff and Cancel Button, 4 Slices, Black

Check Price on Amazon >>

Even the browning of sliced bread is so important. But, how many home toasters consider the specific needs of toasting a bagel? This model does. A unique bagel function allows toasting the cut side of the bagel and warming the outside of the bagel. You will no longer have to make a run to the deli for the perfect morning bagel when you use this toaster.

The first thing you will notice about this toaster is its four slice capacity. Need to make breakfast for the whole family? This countertop kitchen appliance will help you out. Toast a variety of bread, bagels, waffles, or toaster pastries in half the time of a traditional toaster. Everyone will get the toasted treat they want, keeping the whole family happy.

Featuring an adjustable shade selector, you can be sure your toast, or any other treat, will be browned to your standard of perfection time after time.

This toaster features cool-touch sides, so you will not have to worry about it being in reach of little ones. Illuminated buttons help to make functions easily distinguishable. And a crumb tray keeps messes contained.

Pros

  • This toaster features a unique bagel toasting function that perfectly browns the inside and warms the outside.
  • Its four slice capacity helps you make breakfast for a group in half the time of a traditional toaster.
  • Cool-touch sides make it safe for everyone in the family to use.
  • The illuminated buttons ensure you always choose the right selection.
  • A crumb tray helps to contain any mess.
  • The adjustable shade selector allows you to pick your perfect brown.

Cons

  • A few users reported that this toaster broke after a few months of use.
  • Other users noted that the illuminated function buttons stick.

Read Also: Best Toaster for Artisan Bread (7 Great Options)

4 Slice Toaster by Cusibox

Check Price on Amazon >>

This four-slice toaster from Cusibox is a great option for any level of at-home cook.

It comes with the capacity to toast four slices of bread at a time; however, it functions more as a dual capacity toaster with independent control settings, which means that you can toast your bread to different shades simultaneously. Make your toast light while browning toast for a loved one to all the way dark. This way, everyone gets the perfect base for the gourmet toast.

Additionally, this toaster has extra-wide slots with self-centering guides. Whether you are cooking a thin slice of artisanal bread or a thick deli-style bagel, this toaster will conform to your bread. 

Featuring six browning settings, you are sure to find the perfect toast for you and your family. Or, looking for an even easier way to toast? Use the included essential functions of bagel, defrost, and cancel to take the guesswork out of using the toasting dial.

After toasting, cleanup is a breeze with two removal crumb trays and wire storage in the base. This toaster will sit neatly on countertops or in an out-of-the-way cabinet.

Pros

  • Four slice capacity with dual independent control panels ensures everyone gets the toast they desire in half the time of a traditional toaster.
  • Extra-wide slots with self-centering guides provide the perfect fit for any bread or treat.
  • This toaster works with 1650W high power, which safely toasts bread every time.
  • Use the six browning settings on the adjustable dial to find your perfect brown.
  • Or choose the preset bagel, defrost, and cancel buttons for easy no-guess operation.
  • Easy to clean with crumb removal trays and cord storage in the toaster base.

Cons

  • Some users note that the sides of this toaster get very hot while it is in use.
  • Other users report that the toasting may be too powerful, leaving their toast darker than desired even on the lower settings.

Recommended Article: Best Toaster for English Muffins (Top 5 Options)

2 Slice Bagel Toaster by Nostalgia

Nostalgia RTOS200AQ New and Improved Retro Wide 2-Slice Toaster Perfect For Bread, English Muffins, Bagels, 5 Browning Levels, With Crumb Tray & Cord Storage – Aqua

Check Price on Amazon >>

We love this toaster for many reasons, but its unique design takes the cake. This is sure to be a showpiece on any counter.

While this is advertised as a bagel toaster, it can be used for toasting any bread. The benefit of its original bagel toasting design is that the slots are big enough to accommodate almost any size you would like to toast.

While this toaster looks like it could be old, don’t be fooled! It uses 900-watt toasting technology powerful enough to toast through a bagel or thick bread.

You can control the doneness of your toast by using the adjustable dial to any one of the five toasting settings or in between. Or simply use the preset defrost, bagel, and cancel buttons for easy operation.

Highlight this beauty in your kitchen without worrying about the mess. It stays easy to clean with a simple slide-out crumb tray and a storage space for the cord on the bottom of the unit.

Pros

  • Its attractive design will bring nostalgia to your kitchen design.
  • Large toasting slots easily fit a bagel or any other thickly sliced bread.
  • Five browning levels let you choose your perfect toast color.
  • Preset defrost, bagel, and cancel buttons bypass the control dial for simple operation.
  • 900-watt power is safe for the home yet powerful enough to toast through thick bread.
  • It features easy cleaning with a slide-out crumb tray and cord storage under the unit.

Cons

  • Some users reported that this toaster takes a long time to toast, even in the lightest setting.
  • Interestingly, other users noted that this toaster browns everything too quickly, leaving toast darker than desired.

Savoy Toaster by Krups

Check Price on Amazon >>

Krups makes an excellent Savoy toaster model with a reputation for its even browning and easy-to-use operation.

On this toaster, you can choose to use the dial to choose from six browning settings. Use the dial for freedom to choose light to extra dark and anywhere between. Let the numbers on the dial be your guide, but ultimately the brown of your toast is in your control.

Or, for its easiest use, utilize the four preset toaster buttons. Bagel mode ensures the sliced side of your bagel is toasted while the crust side is warmed. Use defrost mode for frozen pastries, toaster hash browns, or waffles. The reheat function allows you to heat without toasting. And the cancel button stops the toaster at any time.

A great unique feature of this toaster is its extra-wide slots with an extra-high lift. This makes for the safe and easy removal of small items.

Pros

  • Extra-wide two-slice capacity can toast any size of bread you need.
  • A browning dial with six settings helps you control cooking to your perfect toast.
  • Four preset modes make for easier operation – bagel, frozen, reheat, and cancel.
  • This toaster is an attractive addition to any kitchen with its sleek stainless steel and black finishing.
  • Extra-high lifts help you reach small items safely.
  • A removable crumb tray assists in the easy cleanup.

Cons

  • Two users noted that this toaster does not automatically turn off, making it a potential fire hazard.

CPT-340 Toaster by Cuisinart

Cuisinart - CPT-340P1 Cuisinart CPT-340 Compact Stainless 4-Slice Toaster, Brushed Stainless

Check Price on Amazon >>

Here is a great model for you if you need the functionality of a four-slice toaster but have limited room in your kitchen. The compact size of this high-capacity toaster will fit easily on any counter or in any small cabinet.

This toaster features an adjustable browning dial with six settings ranging from light to extra dark, giving you control of your brown. In addition to the dial, there are preset buttons for reheat, defrost, bagel, and cancel. These buttons take the guesswork out of operation.

The toasting slots are a spacious one and a half inches wide, which will accommodate even the thickest of bagels.

Also featuring a slide-out crumb tray, this toaster ensures a quick cleanup.

Pros

  • Its compact size is great for small or crowded kitchens.
  • The adjustable dial allows for six browning settings from light to dark and anywhere in between.
  • This toaster features easy operation buttons for defrosting, reheating, bagel, and cancel.
  • Slide-out crumb tray to easily clean the unit.
  • Wide one and a half inch toasting slots fit thick bread and bagels.

Cons

  • Some users note that this toaster will smoke from the debris if you do not clean the crumb tray consistently.

What to Consider When Toasters for Even Browning

Capacity

oven toaster

There are a variety of two and four-slice toasters on the market. Consider which you will need. A simple two-slice toaster is probably best if you only make toast for yourself in the mornings. If you need a toaster to make various breakfast items like bagels, English muffins, and waffles for a group in the morning, a four-slice toaster will be the way.

Further, if you are opting for a four-slice toaster, be sure to choose one with the functionality you need. For some models, all four slices toast the same. In comparison, others let you toast two slices one way and two to a different doneness.

Browning Functions

Generally, you’ll find two main browning operations on most toasters. Usually, toasters will have an adjustable browning dial and preset browning function buttons. 

For the easiest operation, look for toasters with great preset function buttons. Some employ the use of basic “defrost,” “toast,” and “cancel.” While others offer wider ranges like “bagel” and “warm.” Find a toaster with the variety you need.

An adjustable dial offers users more freedom with their toasting doneness. There are usually helpful stops along the way to more easily choose your toasting time. But with the dial function, ultimately, your toast color is in your control.

Cleaning

The downside to making toast? Crumbs. The most efficient way to clean your toaster is by utilizing crumb trays. Most models come with crumb trays built-in. You will want to make sure the crumb tray easily comes out and is easily washable. Bonus if it is dishwasher-safe!

Another consideration is cord storage. If you plan to keep your toaster out on the counter, finding a tidy way to store the cord is important. Find a model with a cord storage space or a retractable cord function.

Wrap Up

toaster crumb tray

There are dozens upon dozens of ways to enjoy toast- from the simple to the gourmet. There are even whole cookbooks dedicated to the art of toast and toppings. When you find the toaster with the functionality you desire, it will be easy to join in on this new frontier of cooking.

Breakfast does not have to be plain toast and jam anymore. Avocado toast is at the height of popularity. Make it for breakfast, or now, with a great new toaster, make it for a group appetizer at a dinner party. Explore the different topping options to please everyone. The possibilities are truly endless.

With a little shopping around, you will be able to find just what you need. Consider toast capacity, browning functions, and cleaning when you make your purchase, and you will be enjoying delicious toast in no time flat.

Out of all the options here, our favorite is the 4 Slice Toaster by Cusibox because of the wide slots and versatility.

Related Article: Best Sifter For Almond Flour

Leave a Comment