Best Tomato Press – Top 10 Options to Buy

Disclosure: As Amazon Associates we earn from qualifying purchases. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no additional cost to you.

Best Tomato Press

Fresh sauce is so much better than the stuff you can buy at the store. All you need is a good tomato press and some tomatoes!

In this article, we discuss the 10 best options currently available and what to look for in the best tomato press for you.

Let’s begin the tomato press reviews:

Quick Summary

Here’s a quick summary of our top picks and why we selected them:

Product Name Why We Picked It
Farm to Table Tomato Press & Tomato Sauce Maker

Farm to Table Tomato Press, Food Strainer/Sauce Maker for Tomato Sauce, Salsa, Marinara, Apple Sauce and more

Check Price on Amazon >>
  • 2.25-quart capacity is plenty of room
  • Durable plastic hopper
  • Mounts to countertops or tables
O.M.A.C. Tomato Mill

Omac Gulliver Tomato Strainer

Check Price on Amazon >>
  • Stainless steel parts
  • Sturdy mounting design
  • Manual crank
OXO Good Grips Food Mill

OXO Good Grips Food Mill

Check Price on Amazon >>
  • Sleek stainless steel design
  • 3 grinding disks made of steel
  • Easy-grip handle and folding non-slip legs
Johnny Apple Sauce Maker Model 250

Johnny Apple Sauce Maker Model 250 Food Strainer

Check Price on Amazon >>
  • High-end aluminum body and crank
  • Durable plastic grip and hopper
  • Multi-purpose design
 

CucinaPro Tomato Strainer

CucinaPro Tomato Strainer - Easily Juices, No Peeling, Deseeding, or Coring Necessary, Farm to Table Garden Tomato Press, Sauce & Puree Maker

Check Price on Amazon >>
 

  • Long-lasting plastic design
  • Suction mount on the bottom
  • Easy to take apart and clean

Best 10 Tomato Presses

Farm to Table Tomato Press & Tomato Sauce Maker

Farm to Table Tomato Press, Food Strainer/Sauce Maker for Tomato Sauce, Salsa, Marinara, Apple Sauce and more

Check Price on Amazon >>

The Farm to Table tomato press comes with a durable plastic hopper that has a 2.25-quart capacity. The press attaches to countertops, tables, and other surfaces.

This unit is perfect for making tomato sauces as well as processing other fruits and veggies. Further, it is dishwasher friendly, easy to clean, and weighs just 2.4 pounds.

The non-stick finish of the press helps the processing of fruits and vegetables even smoother, with no need for peeling before milling.

Pros

  • 2.25-quart capacity is plenty of room
  • Durable plastic hopper
  • Mounts to countertops or tables
  • Dishwasher safe and easy to clean
  • Non-stick finish

Cons

  • It isn’t made of stainless steel or heavy-duty aluminum

Best for:

Small families, couples, and solo cooks want to make their tomato sauce.

CucinaPro Tomato Strainer

CucinaPro Tomato Strainer - Easily Juices, No Peeling, Deseeding, or Coring Necessary, Farm to Table Garden Tomato Press, Sauce & Puree Maker

Check Price on Amazon >>

The CucinaPro Tomato Strainer is our runner-up for the best overall tomato press. It features a durable and long-lasting plastic hopper and suction mount attachment.

The unit weighs just 3-pounds includes a tray for catching sauce and/or puree. It’s easy to take apart, clean, and store. The machine is also useful for more than simply mashing tomatoes.

All things considered, the CucinaPro Tomato Strainer and the Farm to Table unit (our number one pick) are nearly identical.

Pros

  • Long-lasting plastic design
  • Suction mount on the bottom
  • Easy to take apart and clean
  • Works for more than tomatoes
  • Includes tray for catching sauce

Cons

  • The tray that comes with the unit may need to be replaced eventually
  • It isn’t made of stainless steel or heavy-duty aluminum

Best for:

Families, couples, and solo cooks/chefs enjoy saucing tomatoes, apples, and other fruits and veggies.

OXO Good Grips Food Mill

OXO Good Grips Food Mill

Check Price on Amazon >>

The )X) Good Grips Food Mill is a hand-held unit of stainless steel parts with rubber grips. Even the three folding legs are rubber-tipped, so they won’t slip while you’re making tomato sauce!

The unit is 11-inches wide and has a total capacity of 2.3 quarts. The mill includes a high-end stainless steel bowl for catching sauce. Said bowl works excellent as a storage container as well.

Three grinding disks come with the unit, fine, coarse, and medium, all of which consist of durable stainless steel.

Pros

  • Sleek stainless steel design
  • 3 grinding disks made of steel
  • Easy-grip handle and folding non-slip legs
  • 11-inch wide body
  • Includes stainless steel bowl

Cons

  • Somewhat pricey for the size and style (due to its high-quality)

Best for:

Professional cooks, families, and solos who process lots of fresh fruits and vegetables into sauce, salsa, or puree.

Johnny Apple Sauce Maker Model 250

Johnny Apple Sauce Maker Model 250 Food Strainer

Check Price on Amazon >>

The Johnny Apple Sauce Maker Model 250 from Kitchen Coup is heavier duty than the first three options on our list. It has a high-end aluminum body and crank and a long-lasting plastic hopper and cranks grip.

The press comes with clamps and mounts, so you can choose whether to suction mount it or c-clamp it to the table or counter. It also has an extended waste spout for easier processing and clean-up. The machine even includes an optional no-crank motor to make things even easier.

This Apple Sauce Maker is good for much more than turning apples into goo despite the name. It is also great for pressing tomatoes into sauce, salsa, or juice.

Pros

  • High-end aluminum body and crank
  • Durable plastic grip and hopper
  • Multi-purpose design
  • Works well for both home and commercial purposes
  • Optional no-crank motor

Cons

  • More expensive than models that have the same capacity

Best for:

Families of any size, small restaurants, professional cooks, and anyone who makes tomato sauce or salsa are also interested in making apple sauce.

O.M.A.C. Tomato Mill

Omac Gulliver Tomato Strainer

Check Price on Amazon >>

The O.M.A.C Tomato Mill is made in Italy and consists of all stainless steel parts and components. The mill easily and securely mounts to tables and countertops, and mills produce via a manual crank handle.

The unit is as heavy-duty as they come, even though it is lightweight at just 3.3 pounds. The mill is longer lasting than most, so you can crush all the tomatoes!

One major difference between this mill and others is in its mount. The mill is mounted via screws and a plate rather than a c-clamp or suction cup base mount.

Pros

  • Stainless steel parts
  • Sturdy mounting design
  • Manual crank
  • Long-lasting
  • Works well for home and commercial usage

Cons

  • The screws that come with the unit (for the mount) may need to be replaced eventually.

Best for:

Solo cooks, professional chefs, families, and small restaurants looking for a replacement or backup hand-held tomato mill.

Norpro 1952 Jumbo Tomato Press

Norpro 1952 Jumbo Tomato Press, Red

Check Price on Amazon >>

The Norpro 1952 Jumbo Tomato Press has a big red hopper, a crank handle, and heavy-duty plastic components. It weighs around 3 pounds.

The press is perfect for making tomato sauce, apple sauce, and puree from other fruits and vegetables. It comes with multiple stainless steel mesh strains for different consistencies of sauce.

It also comes with a tray for catching sauce as well as a durable suction mount.

Pros

  • Durable plastic handle and grip
  • Ideal for tomatoes as well as apples
  • Stainless steel mesh strainer screens
  • Tray included
  • Built-in suction mount

Cons

  • It could be easier to dismantle and clean
  • Not as heavy-duty as comparable units

Best for:

Families, couples, and solo cooks or chefs looking for a lightweight but heavy-duty tomato sauce maker.

Weston Roma Food Strainer and Sauce Maker

Weston Food Strainer and Sauce Maker for Tomato, Fresh Fruits and Vegetables ,White

Check Price on Amazon >>

The next unit on our list is the Weston Food Strainer and Sauce Maker, a heavy-duty and high-end tomato press. The unit automatically separates the seeds of fruits and veggies from the pulp.

The Weston Food Strainer comes with a suction cup and c-clamp base, so you can pick whichever mounting style best fits your kitchen or tomato sauce-making area. The press is also super easy to use, clean, and store.

The unit weighs a bit more than others, but it also has a much larger 1-gallon capacity (whereas most units max out at 2 or 3 quarts).

Pros

  • High-end heavy-duty, reliable stainless steel screen
  • Multi-purpose screen
  • Suction cup and C-clamp base
  • Additional sizes/extensions available
  • Easy to use and clean
  • Automatically separates seeds from the pulp

Cons

  • May have a larger capacity than you need
  • Costs more than smaller but otherwise similar units

Best for:

Larger families, restaurants, and professional chefs or cooks are looking for a versatile solution for pressing tomatoes into a sauce and turning other fruits and vegetables into puree and more.

Paderno World Cuisine Manual Tomato Crusher

Paderno World Cuisine Manual Tomato Crusher

Check Price on Amazon >>

The Paderno World Cuisine Manual Tomato Crusher is another great pick for one of the best tomato presses available this year. It is heavy-duty, with a hopper and collector of high-grade stainless steel, making it one of the best commercial-grade units mentioned on our list.

The unit is silver and red and works with a strong and reliable clamp-style mounting base. There are numerous attachments available for the machine, including one for saucing berries.

The handle is made from high0end tin, and the rest of the unit is colored in silver and red for a nice and clean aesthetic appeal.

Pros

  • Heavy-duty design
  • Handle made of durable tin
  • Hopper and collector made from stainless steel
  • Commercial-grade unit
  • Additional attachments available

Cons

  • Two to three times heavier than comparable tomato mills
  • More expensive than smaller units

Best for:

Families who cook a lot and professionals who are looking for a diverse enough unit to fulfill multiple saucing, mashing, pressing, and straining needs in the kitchen.

Hungry Artisan Ergonomic Food Mill

Ergonomic Food Mill Stainless Steel With 3 Grinding Milling Discs, Milling Handle & Stainless Steel Bowl - Rotary Food Mill for Tomato Sauce, Applesauce, Puree, Mashed Potatoes, Jams, Baby Food

Check Price on Amazon >>

Number nine on our list, and another excellent candidate for the best tomato press, is the Hungry Artisan Ergonomic Food Mill. The unit is heavy-duty and sports a long-lasting 201 stainless steel design.

The mill is easy to use, take apart, and store. It also works as a veggie steamer, a colander, and for other uses in addition to saucing tomatoes.

The unit comes with 3 premium grinding discs for milling vegetables and fruits. Further, it sports a compact body, allowing you to use up very little space for storing it.

Pros

  • Long-lasting, heavy-duty design
  • Made from 201 stainless steel
  • Easy to use and clean
  • The compact body makes for storage simple
  • 3 grinding discs for milling
  • Side hooks are double welded

Cons

  • More expensive than cheaper but comparable units

Best for:

Families and professionals looking for an affordable and ergonomic solution for straining and saucing tomatoes in addition to other fruits and veggies

VBENLEM 110V Electric Tomato Strainer

VBENLEM 110V Electric Tomato Strainer 450W Commercial Grade Tomato Milling Machine Stainless Steel Tomato Press And Strainer 90-160 Kg/H Pure Copper Motor Food Strainer and Sauce Maker

Check Price on Amazon >>

The VBENLEM Electric Tomato Strainer is a 110V machine that has durable components and is crafted from high-grade materials. Not only is it electric, but it also has an extra-wide 9-inch funnel and trough built-in as well.

The unit weighs 22 pounds and makes more sauce from tomatoes faster than any of the items on our list. It is also the only unit on our list that is fully electric. In comparison, it is also the only item on our list that compares to a KitchenAid electric tomato press on the Kitchenaid stand mixer models.

The machine has a waterproof rating of level II and a powerful, pure copper motor encased in stainless steel protective cover. It makes just as good of a commercial machine as it does domestic kitchen equipment.

Pros

  • Durable materials and components
  • 9-inch wide funnel and trough
  • Easy cleaning and storage
  • Works well for fruits, veggies, sauce, salsa, and more
  • Pure copper motor with stainless steel outer casing

Cons

  • It has an electric motor that needs to be plugged into the wall
  • 5 to 10 times heavier than smaller units

Best for:

Families, small businesses, and professionals need a machine that produces large amounts of sauce in a short period.

What to Look For In A Tomato Press?

Now that we’ve seen the best tomato presses online, it’s time to choose the right one for you.

Below, we discuss what to look for in a tomato press:

Ease of Use

manual tomato press

How hard or easy a tomato press is for you to use is of the utmost importance. The best design for your aunt Judith may not be the best design for you.

For example, if you have a bad elbow, you should avoid a press with a hand crank and look into an electric tomato press instead of one with a crank.

Likewise, if you have a strong right arm and aren’t afraid to use it, a manual press may be just for you.

Hopper Capacity

The capacity of the tomato press hopper dictates how many tomatoes or other fruits and vegetables the unit can process at once.

The average size of a domestic tomato press hopper is 2 to 3 quarts, though they may range up to a few gallons.

Depending on whether you’re just doing garden tomatoes or a whole operation, you may need an extra-large capacity hopper.

Tray

Not all tomato presses come with trays. The ones that do often have extended spouts make it even easier (and less messy) for the tray to catch the sauce as it exits the contraption.

Other units have bowls in place or trays, where the sauce collects as it is produced.

Power or Crank

tomato puree

A big decision is whether or not to go with a unit that is electric or one that works with an old-fashioned crank.

There is no right or wrong way to go; instead, it is best to pick the one that better suits your needs.

A manual crank is just fine if you don’t mind putting in a bit of elbow grease. Otherwise, a unit with power may be the best bet.

This also depends on whether you want to process small or large batches.

Mounting System

Almost all of the best tomato presses come with some sort of mounting system (some don’t, because they are hand-held). It is one of the essential features.

The two most common mounts for tomato presses are c-clamps and suction cups, and both styles are equally effective.

However, some might find that a suction cup base is easier to secure to the countertop. Non-slip legs are always a bonus.

If you’re making small batches, having fancy or multifunctional features may not be necessary.

The third type of mounting involves a bracket or plate and screws, which are also effective but more permanent.

Screens

frozen baby food

The best multi-purpose tomato press for you should come with a variety of screens that best suit your needs.

If you are going to use the unit for more than mashing fresh tomatoes into spaghetti sauce, you’ll need more than one type and size screen.

Most screens range from 1mm to 3mm in thickness and have fine medium or coarse plates that work as a mini food strainer. The thinner the screen, the easier it is to make super fine items such as baby food.

Cost and Warranty

The cost of the best tomato press for you is whatever your budget allows. Based on the choices on our list, expect to spend between $30 and $75 on a manual press and up to $150 for an electric tomato press.

That said, also keep in mind that the best one for you should also come with a warranty or guarantee.

Products that lack a warranty or money-back or replacement guarantee are often less durable (hence their manufacturers don’t bother offering coverage).

Picking the Best Tomato Press for You

Now that you’ve had a look at some of the best tomato press reviews and know what to look for in the best one for you, selecting the right one isn’t so complicated. Just make sure it’s going to be able to handle all of the various kitchen tasks you have planned for it before putting it in your shopping cart!

The Farm to Table Tomato Press is the best choice for small families, couples, and solos.

The press has a moderately large 2.5-quart capacity, a convenient non-stick finish, mounts to a surface, and is fully dishwasher friendly as well. It’s perfect for families, couples, and solo cooks.

Those who have larger families, or are looking for the best tomato press for commercial use, would do better with the Johnny Apple Sauce Maker Model 250.

The Model 250 is great for home use and works well for commercial jobs, as it is high-end aluminum, comes with attachments, and even has an optional motor so you don’t have to crank it.

Note: You may remember a classic product called a Velox Tomato Press.

Leave a Comment